Currently featuring butter and cage-free certified-humane eggs from South Mountain Creamery in Middletown, MD.
Each freshly-baked pie generally serves 10 and comes in a reusable tin.
WHAT ABOUT THE TIN?
Feel free to keep your tin OR return it for a $1 rebate on your next order.
Macaroni & Cheese Pie
Summer is almost here and, frankly, we can't wait any longer. By popular demand, we are pleased to offer Raspberry Almond Crumb Pie. Over a pound and a half of raspberries go into this sweet and tangy pie. We complement this gorgeous bright red deliciousness with a special almond and oat crumb made with farm fresh butter and sweet toasted almonds. Let the sun shine in!Margarita Pie
Nothing says Summer on a fork quite like a slice of delicious and refreshing Margarita Pie. Just squeezed lime juice and grated zest are combined with fresh whipped cream and fine tequila in a salty pretzel crust. Crunchy and creamy...sweet, sour and salty...this pie has it all. Serve frozen or ice cold from the fridge. Either way, deliciousness awaits.
The sour tang of red rhubarb is the perfect pairing for sun-sweetend strawberries. We think that the problem with most strawberry rhubarb pie is that there aren't enough strawberries or rhubarb pieces in it. We solve that problem by adding over 2 pounds of fresh fruit to this delectable American classic. Tastes like your grandmother used to make and like you can't get anywhere else.
Toasted Coconut Cream Pie
This is a coconut lover's pie. Buttery flaky crust is filled with the most cococutty coconut cream that you've ever had. We make our filling from scratch with coconut milk, fresh cream and tender flaked coconut. We top all that with real whipped cream and even more toasted coconut. Is it the best Coconut Cream Pie ever? That's what they tell us, but perhaps you need to try it yourself and be the judge.
Salted Caramel Chocolate Chess
Have you discovered the joys of the sweet and savory combination of chocolate caramel and salt? We have elevated and modernized a southern classic. Our buttery crust is paired with a rich and fudgy dark chocolate filling, topped with our signature homemade caramel and intensified with a sprinkling of crunchy sea salt. Beautiful, decadent and delicious, this pie will satisfy all your senses.
Kentucky Chocolate Walnut Pie
We combine toasted walnuts with Callebaut Belgian chocolate. Just imagine a big oooooey goooooey chocolate chip walnut cookie in a buttery flaky crust. Need we say more? Oh there is one more thing. There is a secret ingredient that we will never reveal... OK, it's bourbon. This is one of our richest and most delicious pies. Serve warm with a scoop of vanilla ice cream and enter pie Nirvana.
Oreo Chocolate Peanut Butter Pie
This irresistible dessert is for the peanut butter lover in your life. We fill a classic Oreo crust with chocolate, peanuts and a rich creamy peanut butter mousse. More Oreos, chocolate and salty peanuts top if off. This pie is a huge hit anytime of the year. Just a warning, this pie really serves closer to 12 people and they still might not be able to finish their slices. It is that rich.
GIFT CERTIFICATES
Looking for that perfect gift? How about a gift certificate for delicious, fresh, handmade pie? Everybody loves pie! Within 24 hours of receiving your gift certificate order, we will e-mail you a customized gift certificate suitable for printing, wrapping, framing...whatever you like. Please indicate the lucky recipient and the gifter from when you place your order. Livin' the Pie Life gift certificates are good for 6 months from day of purchase.