Can I Pre-order?
Unfortunatetly, it is too late to pre-order between now and Thanksgiving. Pre-orders were originally opened on October 16 and we have reached capacity. This may be surprising, but it is true. Please come see us in person for pie (see below).
Post-Thanksgiving Pre-orders will open as follows:
- Pre-order for the Week of December 2 - 5 opens on November 20 at 2 PM
- Pre-order for the Week of December 9 - 13 opens on November 23 at Noon
- Pre-order for the Week of December 16 - 19 opens on December 1 at Noon
- Pre-order for December 22 opens on December 3 at Noon
- Pre-order for December 23 opens on December 4 at Noon
CLICK HERE for more info on December Orders.
How to Get Pie before Thanksgiving
1. COME SEE US - We have 4 more regular bakes between now and Thanksgiving:
- Wednesday (11/18)
- Thursday (11/19)
- Friday (11/20)
- Saturday (11/21).
We anticipate baking between 100-125 pies for general sale on each of those days. Come very early to purchase because we will sell through these pies quite quickly. We can't make more because we are also baking to satisfy pre-orders placed weeks ago. Pies purchased this week can be frozen for Thanksgiving.
We will NOT be open for walk-in sales the week of Thanksgiving with the exception of our LAST CHANCE SALE on Wednesday, November 25 at 2 PM (see above).
_____________________
2. LAST CHANCE SALE - We will have a last chance sale on Wednesday, November 25 at 2 PM. We bake everything we have and sell it on a first-come, first-served basis. We will publish the number of pies available when we have it. For fairness, we will limit the number of pies per person to 3 and the number of apple pies (if available) to 1. There is always a line before the sale begins, so please plan accordingly.
_____________________
3. BUY ELSEWHERE - There are many wonderful pie bakers in the DMV. Please consider giving some love to Acme Pie, Pie Gourmet, Mom's Apple Pie, The Pie Shop or Whisked.
Thank You & A Gentle Request
We are grateful & honored when you choose us for Thanksgiving or any day. We take this responsibility seriously. We make all we can keeping our focus on quality. Quality over quantity, always.
Please be kind. The sad fact is that this is the time of year when we get the most negative online reviews, mostly from people who:
- Were frustrated from not being able to pre-order or waiting in line.
- Waited in line and still didn't get pie.
We get it. You are stressed. Please also be kind.
Our ingredients are fresh and our machines are talented human beings. We are making all we can while maintaining our high quality standards. We cannot "just make more." As things sell out, we try to keep the line informed so they can decide if they want to stay.
Our whole staff is trying their best to serve you. Please be kind.
GIVE THE GIFT OF PIE
The ultimate gift for a pie lover in the DMV, "Pie of the Month" Members enjoy a free pie every month or save up credits for up to six months. Members choose the pie and the date that works for them.
Pie of the Month Membership

A Gift Certificate to Livin' The Pie Life is what they really want. Good for online or in store purchases of ANYTHING that Pie Life makes from scones to cookies to cake to PIE.
Pie Life Digital Gift Card

As Featured In
-
NBC4 Washington
-
Good Day DC
-
Northern Virginia Magazine
-
Sports Illustrated
-
The Tasting Table
-
The Washington Post
Subscribe to email list
Sign up for our email list to get important updates sent right to your inbox! We don't email very often though. For more frequent updates, follow us on Facebook or Instagram.